FIQH MUAMALAT
📖 Chapter ▼
Chapter 5: Concept Of Contract
Chapter 6: Sale-Based Transactions 1
Chapter 7: Sale-based Transactions 2
Chapter 8: Mudarabah
Chapter 9: Musharakah
Chapter 10a: Ijarah
Chapter 10b: Rhan Contract
Chapter 11a: Kafalah
Chapter 11b: Wakalah
Chapter 12: Bay al-Dayn
Chapter 13a: Wadi'ah Contract
Chapter 13b: Contract of Sarf
Table of Contents
Introduction to Ijarah
1. Core Concept
Definition: Ijarah (leasing) is a contract permitted by the al-Qur’an
and Sunnah.
Purpose: It allows people who cannot afford to buy assets to still
access and benefit from them.
Objective: To facilitate public needs and provide ease in life.
2. Literal vs. Technical Meaning
Literal Meaning: Ijarah comes from the root word ’ajjara, which means to recompense, compensate, or give a return. It essentially means "reward for service rendered".
Technical Meaning: In Islamic law, Ijarah covers two distinct
types of contracts.
3. The Two Types of Ijarah
Type A: Hiring Persons (Services)
This refers to employing a person for
wages in
exchange for their work (e.g., a
doctor, lawyer, or teacher).
- Employer: Called the Musta’jir.
- Employee: Called the Ajir.
Type B: Leasing Assets (Usufruct)
This refers to
transferring the usufruct (the
right to use/benefit) of a property to another person in
exchange for rent.
- Lessor: Called the Mu’jir.
- Lessee: Called the Musta’jir.
- Rent: The payment is called Ujrah.
4. Key Exam Distinction
Sale vs. Ijarah:
In a Sale, the corpus (the actual body/ownership) of the property is transferred to the buyer.
In Ijarah, the corpus remains with the owner; only the usufruct (benefit) is transferred.
Classical Jurist Definitions
1. Definitions by School of Thought
You need to know how the different schools define Ijarah slightly differently:
The Hanafis: They define it simply as a
contract pertaining to usufruct with compensation.
The Shafi’is: They are more specific. They define it as a
contract over a usufruct that must
be desirable, known, permissible, and accessible, in exchange for a
known compensation.
The Malikis and Hanbalis: They define it as the
transfer of ownership of a permitted usufruct for a
known period in exchange for
compensation.
2. Common Ground
Despite the small differences, all definitions agree that Ijarah is a
bilateral
contract where the use of a corporeal
object (a physical item) is
exchanged for a
price.
Authority & Evidence of Ijarah
1. Qur’anic Evidence
You can cite these verses to prove Ijarah is valid in the eyes of Allah:
Story of Moses (Surah Al-Qasas 28: 26-27):
One of the women said, "O my father! Hire him! Verily, the best of men for you to hire is the strong, the trustworthy."
- Context: This verse shows a contract based on service for a specific period (serving for eight or ten years) in exchange for marriage.
Recompense for Suckling (Surah At-Talaq 65:6):
"And if they suckle your (offspring), give them their recompense."
- Significance: This validates paying for a service (suckling).
Recompense for Work (Surah Al-Kahf 18:77):
When Moses fixed a wall, he was told, "If thou hadst wished, surely thou couldst have exacted some recompense for it!"
- Significance: This implies that asking for payment for work done is permissible.
2. Sunnah Evidence (Hadith)
These Hadiths set the rules for paying wages and defining the contract:
Timing of Payment: The Prophet (pbuh) said: "Pay the hired worker his
wages before his sweat dries off."
Legal Rule: This indicates the validity of hiring for a specific time
and the obligation to pay promptly.
Certainty of Fee: The Prophet (pbuh) said: "He who hires a person
should inform him of his fee."
Legal Rule: The price/wage must be known (ma'lum) to avoid uncertainty
Warning Against Non-Payment: The Prophet (pbuh) stated that on
Doomsday, he will be an enemy to:
"A man who hired a worker to carry out some work for him, but did not give him his wage."
3. Juristic Consensus (Ijma’)
Unanimous Approval: Ijarah is approved by prominent jurists of all
recognized schools of Islamic law.
The Reasoning:
- The need to utilize the usufruct (benefit) of goods is just as important as the need to utilize the assets themselves.
- It facilitates the standard of life by allowing people to use assets they do not own.
- Consideration for the needs of the people is a basic principle in legalising contracts.
Classifications of Ijarah
1. Based on Subject Matter
Tangible Asset (Ayn):
- This refers to physical assets like properties, transport facilities, and factories.
- The term Ayn is generally used as the opposite of Dayn (debt).
Labour / Non-tangible Asset (Amal):
- This refers to work or services. It is executed by two types of workers:
Ajir Khas: An employee (works for one person exclusively).
Ajir Mushtarak: An independent contractor (can work for multiple
people).
2. Based on Specification of Subject Matter
Ijarah Muayyanah (Specific Source):
- The lease is related to a specific piece of property, such as a particular car or shop.
Ijarah Mawsufa fi al-dhimmah (Liability/Pledge):
- A contract based on a liability to provide a service/benefit, rather than a specific object.
- The lessor assumes the liability to fulfill the defined usufruct.
3. Based on Timing (When it becomes effective)
Ijarah Munjjazah (Instant Lease):
- Comes into effect immediately after the offer is accepted.
- It is not tied to a future event.
Ijarah Mudafah (Lease at a Future Date):
- The effect of the lease is delayed to a fixed future date.
Ijarah Muallaqah (Contingent Lease):
- Effectiveness is tied to the fulfilment of certain conditions or a future event.
- Exam Note: The Majority of jurists consider this type invalid.
4. Based on Contractual Relationship
Ijarah Tashghiliyyah (Operating Lease):
- Usually conducted by business companies or IFIs.
- Key criteria: It is not tied with a purchasing agreement.
Ijarah Tamwiliyyah (Financing Lease):
- Usually conducted by IFIs (Islamic Financial Institutions).
- Key criteria: It is tied to purchasing or gifting the asset at the end.
- Widely used in real estate, machinery, and equipment.
Conditions of Ijarah Contract
1. General Contract Conditions
Known Consideration: Both parties must precisely know the consideration
(payment/wage), whether it is for the usufruct of a service or the usufruct of
an asset.
Fixed Duration & Purpose:
- The period of the contract must be fixed (e.g., 1 year, 6 months).
- The purpose of the lease must be clearly specified (e.g., "for residence," "for storage").
- Ownership Requirement: The lessor (Mu'jir) must be the absolute owner of the rented item, or a valid agent or guardian of the owner.
2. Responsibilities of the Parties
Lessor’s Responsibility (Maintenance):
- It is the duty of the lessor to maintain the leased property.
- They must ensure the property remains in a condition that allows the lessee to retain the benefit of it.
Lessee’s Responsibility (Damages):
- If the lessee intentionally damages the leased property, the lessor has the right to:
Terminate the lease agreement.
- Seek compensation for the damage.
3. Specific Rules for Sub-letting & Services
Sub-letting:
- The lessee is allowed to sub-let immovable property (like a house or land).
- Condition: This is valid provided there is no restriction forbidding it in the original agreement.
Ijarah of Services:
- For service contracts, the benefit/work must be made known by a statement describing the nature of the service being offered.
Applications & Issues
1. Ijarah Thumma al-Bai’ (Lease Ending with Ownership)
- Concept: This is a hybrid contract where the intention of the lessor is to keep ownership only until the end of the lease duration.
- Transfer: Upon completion of the Ijarah, the ownership is transferred to the tenant/lessee.
- Modes of Transfer: There are four common ways this transfer is achieved :
- Automatic Transfer: If rents are paid fully, the lessee automatically gets ownership.
- Token Price: Lessee is entitled to purchase the asset for a token price after paying full rent.
- Market Price: Lessee is entitled to purchase the asset at the prevailing market price.
- Promise to Sell: The lessor promises to sell the asset at real market value upon completion.
2. Sale and Lease Back (Sukuk Ijarah)
- Definition: This involves the sale of property to sukuk holders, and subsequently leasing back the asset from them, with a promise to buy back the asset upon maturity.
- Key Issues:
- The legality of selling the corpus (asset body) with a condition to lease it back.
- The repurchasing of the asset by the issuer at the maturity date.
3. The 'Inah' Controversy
This is a major area of debate regarding Sale and Lease Back structures.
- Definition of Inah: Inah generally refers to a sale and buyback arrangement (often used to bypass interest). It is applicable to both the corpus and the usufruct.
- The Majority View:
- They do not consider Sale and Lease Back as Inah, implying it is permissible.
- The Opposing View (Minority):
- They consider this transaction akin to Inah and therefore nullify (invalidate) it.
- Reasoning: They argue it is not permissible to sell an asset for cash with a stipulation to lease it back if the total rental payments plus the repurchase price exceed the original cash price paid by the sukuk holders.
0 Comments